Well, at this point, it's the world against the Prophets. There are 2 main forces hitting the Prophets really hard, and, combined, they're winning.
One of the most over-rated players is definitely rekk323. He's the 3rd best player in the world, but he's a noob and he doesn't know what he's doing. (He said it himself). This guy is way too cocky and in over his head, he bosses people around like he's the best person ever and literally thinks he's all that.
One of the most underrated players, in my opinion, is this guy Scott-The-Erogenous. He's brave, for he switched over from the Prophets to the Condemned, and he's great. He has the highest city average by at least 1,000 points at 12,478 and he's in 62nd place. He's also holding his own against the best alliance in Sparta as they're bombarding him with attacks.