DeletedUser
Guest
well i guess we just need to wait for eclipse to get 'round to it then
as i said, it's not perfect and that is the drawback of my proposed system. however i think that the total BP gained by an alliance viewed that way only has historical significance but none i.t.o. performance statistics.I do not like this idea. The BP gained as an alliance shows how much BP you gained as an alliance, as a team. And I don't think that the alliance should lose BP when a member leaves, cos that member got the BP in the alliance, probably with help from others from the alliance.
in my experience, players are either aggressive or they are not and the alliance they are in will not change that. however, being in a better alliance will give some less experienced players more confidence to build more attacking units. so while your point is not wrong, i don't think it's 100% correct either. as for the BP having been earned by the alliance, obviously it hasn't, but it gives a better representation of that alliances strength with that extra player added imo.To those saying that when a player changes alliances his total bp should be added as well, what if that player reduces his/her amount of aggression. What if the rest of the alliance sucks. Do you honestly think that increase in bp has been earned by the ALLIANCE. No!
i agree with you on this 100%. i was reluctant to add it to my OP at first, but it looks increasingly as though everybody is on this wavelengthIn short, I would only be for this as long as both stats are shown.
in my experience, players are either aggressive or they are not and the alliance they are in will not change that. however, being in a better alliance will give some less experienced players more confidence to build more attacking units. so while your point is not wrong, i don't think it's 100% correct either. as for the BP having been earned by the alliance, obviously it hasn't, but it gives a better representation of that alliances strength with that extra player added imo.
i would like it to be in 1.x worlds too, but will take what i can get really!Just a thought, maybe make it a 2.0 only addition? Or possibly one initiated by the popular vote in a world?