DeletedUser13405
Guest
Proposal: While shared BP is a great idea, it seems a bit unfair that a player who city is under siege will receive BP from break attempts. If possible, the city under siege should not receive any BP from siege breaking attempts.
Have you Checked the DNS and PSI lists in the Archives? Is this idea similar to one that has been previously suggested?
Yes and No.
Reason: It is difficult enough to open slots in later stages of the game. Giving up several victory processions to your opponent because you successfully defended your siege of his/her city only makes it more difficult to grow. Also, is that not rewarding someone for losing their city?
Finally, situations can arise whereby the person who lost the city gets more BP from the conquer than the attacker. Aren't defenders given enough advantages already?
Details: This may be a coding issue that cities under siege would not receive shared BP from conquer break attempts.
Visual Aids: N/A
Balance: I think this idea brings shared BP into balance.
Abuse Prevention: I can't see a situation where this may be abused.
Summary: BP should be earned, not gifted when you lose a city.
Have you Checked the DNS and PSI lists in the Archives? Is this idea similar to one that has been previously suggested?
Yes and No.
Reason: It is difficult enough to open slots in later stages of the game. Giving up several victory processions to your opponent because you successfully defended your siege of his/her city only makes it more difficult to grow. Also, is that not rewarding someone for losing their city?
Finally, situations can arise whereby the person who lost the city gets more BP from the conquer than the attacker. Aren't defenders given enough advantages already?
Details: This may be a coding issue that cities under siege would not receive shared BP from conquer break attempts.
Visual Aids: N/A
Balance: I think this idea brings shared BP into balance.
Abuse Prevention: I can't see a situation where this may be abused.
Summary: BP should be earned, not gifted when you lose a city.